28 Holiday Cookies to Bake This Year

Looking for the perfect cookie for the holiday season? Look no farther than this list of cookies, containing bar cookies, drop cookies, hand-formed cookies and more! You’re bound to find EXACTLY what you’re looking for in this cookie list!

This year’s Sweetest Season Cookie Exchange has come and gone, and I’m reeling over what was shared because y’all, we had a talented and amazing bunch of bakers this year.

Also, we have 28 new cookie recipes that are now residing on my must-try list.

(Someone will come here and bake them all with me, right? And then help me eat them, too?)

Whether you’re looking for drop cookies, no bake cookies, cookies that you cut out or more, chances are, we’ve got a cookie for you on this year’s holiday cookie list! You can bake them for a cookie exchange, Christmas Eve (or Christmas Day), Hanukkah and more, too, because, well, you can’t go wrong with sharing cookies during the holiday season.

I am so excited to share some amazing cookie recipes you absolutely need to bake before the holiday season is over.

Looking for more cookie inspiration? Check out Winston’s Favorite Holiday Cookies, as well as 39 Cookies for Santa and 41 Holiday Cookie Recipes You’ve Gotta Bake This December!

Brownies & Bar Cookies

1

www.baumassfoods.com

Vegan Double Chocolate Pecan Cookie Bars

How perfect do these cookies bars look? Calling for tons of chocolate and pecans, they sounds pretty heavenly to me. Oh, and they're VEGAN! Perfection!

Get the Recipe

2

www.crumbtopbaking.com

Chocolate Chai Spice Crumble Bars

These vegan, gluten free CRUMBLE bars are the perfect treat for Santa and friends, especially if you're into warming spices. Personally, I'm into it, and y'all know I cannot wait to try it because chai + chocolate + bar cookies sounds pretty delish to me.

Get the Recipe

3

www.missmollymoon.com

Old Fashioned Orange Slice Bars

While I've never had an Orange Slice Bar, I love the sound of them because, well, I love a good citrusy dessert. These are Molly's mom's recipe, and my goodness, do they look amazing for sharing this holiday season!

Get the Recipe

4

www.thefreshcooky.com

Salted Chocolate Graham Bites

Salty sweet dessert lover? These Graham bites are for you! (And me–because I love 'em, too.) They're chewy and all kinds of perfect for sharing… or just making for yourself. No judgment here!

Get the Recipe

Cutout and Shaped Cookies

5

www.sugarlovespices.com

Ciambelline Sarde

These classic Sardinian Sandwich Cookies are shaped like flowers and filled with jam OR chocolate hazelnut spread. These wouldn't last long in our household, that's for sure. The question is: Which filling would you choose first?

Get the Recipe

6

e2bakesbrooklyn.com

Pretzel Shortbread

Pretzel cookies with a drizzle of dark chocolate on 'em… and a sprinkle of salt? Oh, YES. I'm totally all in for these shortbread cookies.

Get the Recipe

7

www.thinkfruitful.com

Orange Spice Cookies

Sugar and spice and everything nice… with ORANGE! I love a good citrusy cookie (and dessert, in general), so y'all know I adore the combination of flavors in these cookies. What kind of cookie cutter would you use for yours?

Get the Recipe

Drop Cookies

8

homespunseasonalliving.com

Old-Fashioned Spicy Hermit Cookies

Before this year's Sweetest Season, I had never heard of a Hermit Cookie, let alone a SPICY one. Homespun Seasonal Living has enlightened me, and I cannot wait to bake these. These vintage cookies are filled with dried fruits, nuts and coffee… so you know they're going to be a winner!

Get the Recipe

9

rootsy.org

Chocolate Cranberry Sauce Cookies

Cookies made with cranberry sauce AND chocolate? Sign me up! I'm loving the combination of flavors in these drop cookies because cranberries and chocolate are two of my favorite things this time of year, though I've never had them together. Fixing that ASAP!

Get the Recipe

10

www.meandmypinkmixer.com

Jam Thumbprint Cookies

To me, Thumbprint Cookies are perfect for sharing during the holiday season because you can fill them with so many different ingredients! I love these classic Jammy ones from Me and My Pink Mixer!

Get the Recipe

11

marisamoore.com

White Chocolate Macadamia Oatmeal Cookies

Looking for a gluten free cookie for the holidays? Marisa Moore has brought her gorgeous and festive flavored White Chocolate Macadamia Oatmeal Cookies to this year's cookie table… and they sound divine.

Get the Recipe

12

strengthandsunshine.com

Vegan White Chocolate Peppermint Cookies

These Vegan White Chocolate Peppermint Cookies are also gluten free AND allergy free, so they're perfect for sharing with your friends and family members who have intolerances. But also, they're perfect for YOU, whether or not you're gluten free or have food allergies, because they have such amazing flavors.

Get the Recipe

13

Potato Chip Cookies

These Potato Chip Cookies are a long-time favorite of my family's because they combine salty and sweet into one bite-sized cookie. Filled with actual potato chips AND pecans, they never last long in our house.

Get the Recipe

14

Lemon Drop Cookies

Looking for a lighter, fluffy cookie this season? Lemon Drops are the way to go! Named after the classic cocktail, these cookies are light and bright with a sweet-tart glaze that makes 'em super balanced. I bet Santa wouldn't mind a few of these on his cookie plate…

Get the Recipe

Hand-Formed Cookies

15

www.idigpinterest.com

Christmas Cake Mix Cookies Three Ways

Cake mix cookies are SO SMART and make life so much easier if you're on a time crunch! I Dig Pinterest has given us THREE WAYS to make and decorate them… and I, for one, think it's brilliant.

Get the Recipe

16

lifeloveandgoodfood.com

Ginger Molasses Cookies

Oh, these Ginger Molasses Cookies are a classic from Life, Love and Good Food, and they sing of the seasonal flavors I think of whenever we discuss the holidays. What a combination, right?

Get the Recipe

17

smackofflavor.com

Snowman Peanut Butter Cookies

These Snowman Peanut Butter Cookies are just too cute! And I have no doubt they're going to be a blast to make with kids because how can you NOT have fun making a face like that on your cookies?!

Get the Recipe

18

houseofnasheats.com

Glazed Jam Thumbprint Cookies

Now these thumbprints are simply GORGEOUS and filled with your favorite jam, and oh my goodness, I could eat the whole batch. The question is: Which jams are you going to use? And will you go the extra mile to make the vanilla glaze, too?

Get the Recipe

19

theschmidtywife.com

White Chocolate Dipped Peppermint Cookies

White chocolate and peppermint just so so beautifully together this time of year, and The Schmidty Wife brings the flavors in her dipped cookies that are also studded with peppermints! I know these taste exactly like the holiday season!

Get the Recipe

20

savoryspin.com

Easy Oatmeal Cranberry Cookies

Oatmeal and cranberries in a cookie sounds absolutely delicious to me because I love these flavors separately AND together. Savory Spin knows her flavors, and I have no doubt these easy cookies are utterly scrumptious and perfect for sharing!

Get the Recipe

21

www.pookspantry.com

Almond Biscotti with Golden Raisins

Have you ever made biscotti? If you haven't, you need to because this Almond Biscotti with Golden Raisins (that are soaked in AMARETTO!) are utterly perfect. I've had some of Pook's Pantry's biscotti before, and let me just say: 10/10 recommend.

Get the Recipe

22

hellolittlehome.com

Peppermint Thumbprint Cookies

Thumbprints filled with PEPPERMINT goodness? Could these cookies get any cuter OR be any more Christmasy? No, they can not… so we should probably bake them ASAP, assuming you adore peppermint as much as I do.

Get the Recipe

23

www.bunsenburnerbakery.com

Lemon Thumbprint Cookies

Thumbprint cookies filled with LEMON sounds like the perfect tart-sweet cookie of my dreams. As someone who's gotten into citrus-flavored sweets in her 30s, I love seeing and experiencing more lemons and other citruses in cookies. In fact, I could probably eat the entire batch of these…

Get the Recipe

No Bake Cookies

24

www.crumbtopbaking.com

Crispy Peanut Butter Balls

These vegan, naturally gluten free peanut butter balls are perfect for making a large batch and then sharing them with the people you love most! Crumb Top Baking brings the flavors with these dark chocolate-covered peanut butter balls, and they're perfect for the season.

Get the Recipe

Other Cookies

25

joybileefarm.com

Anise Flavored Gluten Free Pizzelles

Pizzelle Cookies are one of my family's favorites, but we've never made them. I love that these pizzelles, which are traditionally flavored with anise seed, are also gluten free!

Get the Recipe

26

joybileefarm.com

Gluten Free Chocolate Pizzelle Cookies

These pizzelle cookies are on the sweeter end of the spectrum with chocolate! Also made gluten free, these are great for sharing with friends and neighbors!

Get the Recipe

27

feastandwest.com

Chocolate Chip Cookies Shots

Chocolate chip cookie dough is shaped into a shot glass, coated in chocolate and then filled with your favorite liquid, whether it's a drink or a shot of milk. Either way, these are a PERFECT cookie to share this holiday season and to leave out on Christmas Eve…

Get the Recipe